The effect of Real Estate on the Economy of a Nation

real estate stock market

Financial market commentators tend to focus on the price of bonds and stocks but the majority of the wealth of individuals in developed nations is skewed towards residential property. In the US, the largest residential real estate market, that asset value is around $34trln, about the same as the capitalization of the entire US stock market. For the majority of workers, the single largest asset they own, notwithstanding the encumbrance of mortgage debt, is their home. They may have pension savings and other stores of value but these pale into insignificance beside their investment in property.

In terms of the economic health of a nation, the level of private debt and the value of private assets has an enormous influence on household spending patterns. During the last decade, interest rates have fallen to among the lowest levels ever recorded. This has made debt easier to finance and has driven stock, bond and property prices higher. Economists refer to this boost to prices resulting from the lowering interest rates as a raising of the present value of assets. The same process can, of course, be reversed by a raising of interest rates; this will lower the present value of assets causing asset prices to fall.

There are, of course, other factors which influence the price of residential real estate. Supply has always been important. As Mark Twain is said to have advised, ‘Buy land, they ain’t making it anymore.’ Demand is an equally important driver of prices. In this respect demographic forces play an important role. The ‘baby-boom’ generation, which drove the price of housing during the 1980s and 1990s, is an obvious example of demand outstripping supply. A nation’s immigration policy can also influence the equilibrium price. Government policy with regard to housing in general – and affordable housing in particular – is another important factor. The transactional costs of buying and selling property have remained stubbornly high (especially in the US) and, whilst property technology has reduced some of the costs, real estate fees have not mirrored that of the stock market where transaction costs have been falling for several decades.

Aside from transaction fees, labour force participation, the unemployment rate and average earnings are additional influences on the fortunes of the housing market. The post-financial crisis rise of the part-time employee, saddled with all the uncertainties that entails, has tempered the positive effect of a lowering of interest rates. This decline in job security has been offset by the increasing number of older workers who have chosen to continue in employment. Their steady stream of income means that the debt-servicing capacity of the market has increased in aggregate. Older workers are generally less indebted but the overall effect of higher labour force participation is supportive of asset prices. If older workers do not need to draw down so aggressively on savings, or seek equity release from their property assets, then demographers’ predictions of a wave of generational dissaving are postponed.

A glance at the IMF Global Real House Price Index since 2000 shows the impact of the financial crisis; unsurprisingly, the inflection point coincided with the economic downturn:

Source: IMF, BIS, ECB, Federal Reserve, Savills, National Statistics Agencies

The sluggish period in 2000-2001 was a hangover from the bursting of the technology stock bubble. Once markets cleared, most of the subsequent growth in prices between 2002 and 2008 was driven by an expansion of bank credit – interest rates actually rose after 2004. In the US this was the era of covenant-lite loans and the proliferation of an alphabet soup of securitised mortgage products. That bubble also burst and in a spectacular fashion. The two years following the financial crisis saw a sharp reduction in the availability of mortgage products and an even sharper reduction in interest rates. The Eurozone debt crisis of 2011 held residential property prices back for a little longer, and the prospect of a large Eurozone bank default – and the associated systemic risk to the global financial system – acted as a brake to credit expansion. The world changed in July 2012 when the then-President of the European Central Bank, Mario Draghi, announced that he would do, ‘whatever it takes,’ to avert another financial crisis. Markets regained confidence, stocks rallied, credit spreads narrowed and the global housing market renewed its upward trajectory.

So much for the history of housing prices; where do we stand in terms of housing affordability and what should we expect looking ahead? To begin to answer this question it is essential to understand housing affordability:

As the chart above reveals, between Q1 2015 and Q1 2019 house prices have outstripped growth in income in half the countries monitored by the OECD. The US, which is the largest economy in the group, has seen prices run around 8% ahead of incomes.

Nor has the rise in housing prices been matched by rental income:

Source: IMF. OECD

The lagged behaviour of rental income is unsurprising; rental yields are closely correlated to bond yields which in turn are influenced by the monetary policies of central banks. As official rates have fallen and quantitative easing has driven bond yields lower, so rental yields have stagnated or fallen – why rent, when it is so inexpensive to borrow and buy? In Portugal, for example, absolute rental costs have actually fallen relative to income.

Notwithstanding the other factors alluded to above, the greatest influence on the direction of global residential real estate prices over the past decade has been a combination of the cost of finance and the availability of credit:

Source: IMF, Haver Analytics

The period shown in the chart above is Q1 2018 to Q1 2019. The decline in credit growth seen in a small number of countries is mostly a hangover from previous, mostly domestic, crises.

The charts above might give the impression that real estate valuations are stretched, but a different approach to affordability is to compare mortgage interest payment costs to house prices. This is the day-to-day cost to individuals of owning property using borrowed money.

Official interest rates have fallen in all developed countries, government bond yields have followed suit, but as interest rates approached the zero-bound many banks became reluctant to reduce their mortgage lending rates by the same degree. This is understandable since banks traditionally take sight deposits from current account holders, on which they pay little or no interest, and lend longer term at a spread over central bank base rates.

In Europe, banks have traditionally lent at a variable rate of between 1.5% and 3% above the central bank official rate. For the Eurozone’s commercial banks times are hard, as the current average variable rate for a mortgage rate has come down to 1.4%. Historical Europe-wide mortgage data is difficult to source but the average German Bank Lending Rate provides a reasonable surrogate. The chart below tracks the rate since 2003:

Source: CEIC Data

The current Bank Lending Rate is 2.1%, which is just under half a percent higher than the average German Mortgage Rate (1.63%). For simplicity, let us assume that the spread between the Bank Lending Rate and the Mortgage Rate has been stable – credit spreads have tended to compress as rates have approached zero. On this basis, the cost of borrowing to buy a property has fallen from around 5.75% in 2008 to 1.63% today, an effective reduction in interest payments of 72%. Put another way, the interest payments on a Eur100,000 mortgage in 2008 would cost the same as a mortgage of Eur352,000 today. Eurozone property prices have not tripled in the last decade. The debt service cost of buying Eurozone property is therefore substantially lower today than it was a decade ago.

The US mortgage market is different from that of the Eurozone since the majority of US mortgages are long-term (30 years) and fixed rate. Whilst the magnitude is less extreme, the chart below shows a similar pattern to Europe. US mortgage rates have fallen from around 6.5% to 3.5% over the post-financial crisis period. The interest cost of a $100,000 mortgage in 2008 would cover $186,000 of borrowing today:

Source: Federal Reserve Bank of St Louis

Similar calculations could be made in Japan, although a monetary policy which targets a 10-year government bond yield to maturity of zero begins to make a mockery of the extrapolations above. If one were able to secure a mortgage at a negative interest rate, as it has recently become possible to do in Denmark, by this warped logic it would make economic sense to borrow the absolute maximum a bank would be prepared to lend. Why then have Danish property prices not exploded to the upside? To misquote Coleridge, it is the suspension of belief on the part of the average Dane. If a bank is willing to pay you to borrow, something is rotten in the State of Denmark.

Overpriced or Bargain Basement

After this short review of global residential real estate it is tempting to conclude that, so long as interest rates do not rise substantially and demand outstrips supply, prices should continue to increase. The problem with this logic is that the current level of interest rates is distorting the nature of global economic growth.

Government borrowing has been a key driver of the economic expansion of the past decade. Although some would argue that government debt is heading to infinity and beyond, at some point we should expect this debt to be repaid. But why repay at all when interest rates (and even some mortgage rates) are negative? This brings to mind another quote from Hamlet, Polonius’s advice to his son:

‘Neither a borrower nor a lender be,
For loan oft loses both itself and friend,
And borrowing dulls the edge of husbandry.’

Source: American Institute for Economic Research

You May also Like this

real estate professionals
Things Real Estate Professionals ...

During this , social unrest and an upcoming election, a lot has...

Virtual Real Estate
Blockchain Technology to monetize ...

In the “real” world, has historically been seen as a viable investment....

brrrr
What is the BRRRR ...

If you're part of the business or plan on breaking into it,...

Macroeconomic
Macroeconomic Issues in Real ...

Understanding macroeconomic risk is critical to a successful strategy. While this form...

illiquidity premium
What is Illiquidity Premium ...

Illiquidity premium is the excess return an investor stands to earn in...

renewal
The procedure for the renewal ...

According to Section 1 of the , the law vests the ownership of...

pandemic
Post COVID-19 pandemic and ...

Adapt. Innovate. Accelerate. This is the mantra for any business right now...

Real Estate Wholesaling
Real Estate Wholesaling Pros ...

wholesaling is a kind of arbitrage in which a party known as a wholesaler...

stamp duty
The new Stamp Duty ...

Taxes are one of the ways through which the Government generates revenue...

WFH
How Work From Home ...

Google has announced that it will continue with work from home (WFH)...

Investment Portfolio
Investment Portfolio Diversification in ...

Months after the onset of Covid-19, we continue to see its impact...

path of progress
What is path of ...

As a , you may have heard the term path of progress before. The...

Virtual Real Estate
Increase of Virtual Real ...

Prospective buyers getting their first glimpse of potential homes through smartphone cameras...

Property Managers
Operational Guidelines Property Managers ...

The pandemic crisis has thrown nearly all industries for a loop, and...

Commercial real estate
The Effect of the ...

The real estate industry is changing, a change that started before the...

Disruptive Real Estate
Disruptive Real Estate and ...

What do Google, Microsoft, Facebook, Twitter, Visa and American Express all have...

Post-Pandemic
Outlook of Post-Pandemic Commercial ...

The COVID-19 pandemic is having a transformative impact on (CRE) markets. The...

invest in real estate
Reasons you should Invest ...

Your current financial stability doesn’t guarantee that you’ll be free from financial...

Retirement
Real Estate Investments for ...

Real estate can be an incredible tool to help you prepare and...

Real Estate Industry
Tips to better understand ...

If you're looking to buy or sell property, it's important to have...

Real Estate Investment
Ways of getting involved ...

While many people get involved in real estate to generate a return...

value
How to assess the ...

If you’re investing in property, you’ll need accurate real estate valuations to...

Real Estate Investors
Guiding Principles for Real ...

While the national faces significant uncertainty right now, it's important to recognize...

Real Estate Investing
The largest benefits of ...

Real estate is one of the best possible ways to drive personal...

The Real Estate Market
How the Real Estate ...

If you're looking to buy or sell property, it's important to have...

Remote Working
Remote Working and its ...

Many ask if the remote working culture will be here to stay,...

buying and selling
Real Estate Buying and ...

EASTON — agents and their colleagues have adapted quickly to the new...

unstable market
Investing in Real Estate ...

The industry is filled with its share of ups and downs. In...

real estate investments
Real Estate Investments to ...

There are several types of real estate , but most fall into...

office space
Will the Pandemic make ...

A myriad of publications have already pronounced office space a trend of...

How the pandemic will affect Resident Demands in the future
How the pandemic will ...

The current pandemic and global response is a once-in-a-lifetime event that has...

digital asset
How Real Estate is ...

Yesterday, I had a call with one of my company’s larger customers....

Real Estate Agents
Ways Real Estate Agents ...

There is a reason companies like Tesla have such a loyal customer...

Commercial real estate investments
Commercial real estate investments ...

real estate investments will fare well in the face of the coronavirus, which...

Operational Real Estate
The importance of Operational ...

New York, NY—With the shift towards buying an experience over buying a...

Passive Income
Ways to Earn Passive ...

Passive income is an important factor in building wealth and achieving financial...

millennials
The Future of Real ...

We've all seen studies on millennials circulating around the internet. As the...

land
Things to consider before ...

Looking to buy land to build your dream home? Land is the...

Angel Investing
Angel Investing versus Real ...

I’m often asked what my preference is when comparing angel investing to...

Bitcoin Investment
The comparison of Real ...

Two popular avenues, real estate and bitcoin, have been making waves in...

mortgage
How to find the ...

If you’re looking to buy a home or in a single family...

Reserves
The importance of Reserves ...

Private real estate affords investors considerable control over their , from how...

attorney
The importance of an ...

Engaging the right attorney helps you avoid costly mistakes in deals. Especially...

bundle of rights
The comparison of bundle ...

What is “,” really? Most people might say it's the land and/or...

Lagos State Real Estate Law
Laws guiding the Use ...

The regulatory bodies in real estate include but are not restricted to the following;...

Commercial Real Estate Tech
2020 Top Commercial Real ...

Deloitte’s 2020 Commercial Real Estate Outlook surveyed 750 owners, operators and investors in 10...

Mortgage notes
Guide on investing in ...

Most new investors in active real estate start with a traditional method...

real estate rehab
Stages of Real Estate ...

If you play your cards right, rehabbing houses can be very rewarding...

Multifamily
Investing in Multifamily Real ...

Millions of Americans depend on cash flow generated by long-term investment portfolios,...

ways to invest in real estate
Ways to invest in ...

There is a common misconception that real estate investing requires property ownership....

rental properties
Pros and Cons of ...

Many investors understand why they should invest in real estate for the...

urban regeneration
Planners urge Lagos State ...

Planners have charged the Lagos state government to do more detailed master...

Commercial Real Estate Technologies
Trending Commercial Real Estate ...

The commercial real estate industry has entered a new phase of technology...

Real Estate Location as a franchisee
Tips to secure the ...

Real estate site selection has the power to make or break any...

Remote Workers
How Remote Workers affect ...

As more people are able to work from home, housing priorities have...

5G Technology
5G Technology REITs

There is a revolution going on. You’ve probably heard the term 5G...

buyers
Questions Home Buyers should ...

Buying a home is one of the most expensive decisions you'll ever...

remodeling
Mistakes to avoid when ...

Americans are spending less on home renovations than they were at this...

Real Estate Market
Reasons for investing in ...

Are you thinking about purchasing your first piece of real estate? Investing...

real estate funds and REITs
Differences between real estate ...

Are you ready to invest in real estate? Real estate funds and real...

Agents and Brokers
Differences between Real Estate ...

Real estate transactions often involve significant amounts of money. As a result,...

real estate crowdfunding
Real Estate Crowdfunding Investment

Ask a rich person how they got rich, and there’s a good...

Investing Real Estate Market
Investing in the right ...

Investing in real estate is tremendously exciting, and can be very lucrative....

housing in Nigeria
FMBN to build 100 ...

Ahmed Dangiwa, Managing Director, Federal Mortgage Bank of Nigeria (FMBN), said the...

local real estate market trends
Factors that determine Local ...

Real estate markets trend between times of boom and bust, depending on a...

invest in real estate
Affordable ways to invest ...

Real estate can help diversify a portfolio. One way to grow your...

real estate digital finance
8 top concepts of ...

In all history there has never been a more profound era of...

appraisal services
Why you need appraisal ...

Real estate investing can be an excellent way to earn passive income....

Real Estate Investment
Determining your Real Estate ...

Malcolm Gladwell states that it takes 10,000 hours of practice to become...

real estate agent
12 Qualities in Selecting ...

Purchasing a home is a huge financial commitment, so finding the right...

National Urban Development Policy
Revision of the National ...

The long-awaited overhaul of the National Urban Development Policy (NUDP) has been...

Warehouse
Capitalizing on the Warehouse ...

Everyone knows that retail is evolving, and common thought says that retail...

Mixed-Use Real Estate
Benefits of Mixed-Use Real ...

In cities, mixed-use real estate is hidden everywhere. Someone likely lives above...

dead capital
Real Estate Dead Capital ...

PwC estimates that Nigeria holds at least $300 billion or as much...

Post your Comments

NAME *
EMAIL *
Website

error: Content is protected !!
%d bloggers like this: